Finding the right pool cover reel for above ground pools can make seasonal maintenance much easier and extend the life of your cover. The best models combine durability, smooth operation, and compatibility with your pool size — but tradeoffs exist. For example, some reels prioritize affordability but may lack long-term sturdiness, while premium options offer features like locking mechanisms or rust-resistant materials at a higher price. The VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel stands out as the overall top choice for its balance of quality and price. Meanwhile, the Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel offers premium features suitable for larger pools. Continue reading for a detailed comparison and help in choosing the reel that best fits your needs.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The most versatile reels accommodate a wide range of pool sizes, often 18-24 feet wide, providing flexibility for different above ground pools.
- Durability varies significantly; models with rust-resistant and weatherproof materials tend to last longer but often come at a higher cost.
- Ease of use features like locking mechanisms and smooth-rolling designs reduce manual effort and improve safety during operation.
- Price differences reflect build quality and added features; investing a bit more can pay off in longevity and convenience.
- Compatibility with different pool shapes (round vs. oval) is less common but worth considering for specific pool setups.
| VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel for Inground Swimming Pools |  | Best Overall for Versatility and Durability | Model Name: Vingli pool reel | Model Number: Vingli pool reel | UPC: 611890868436 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel for 24 ft Above Ground Pools |  | Best for Large Above Ground Pools with Adjustable Fit | Fits Pool Size: 19-24 ft wide | Material: Aluminum | Diameter: 3.5 ft | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel for 12-18 ft Above Ground Pools |  | Best for Small to Medium Pools with Easy Operation | Fits Pool Width: 12-18 ft | Material: Resin | Color: Blue | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Essential 52000 Above Ground Pool Solar Reel System |  | Best Heavy-Duty System for Reliable Solar Cover Deployment | Compatibility: Various tube kits (sold separately) | Construction: Heavy-duty, non-corrosive | Installation: Socket mountable | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 18FT Pool Cover Reel Set for Inground Pools, Fits 6-18 ft Wide Pool |  | Best Adjustable Reel for Inground Pools up to 18 ft | Brand: Nollapo | Model: NLA-1 | Model Number: NLA-1 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Intex 28051E Solar Cover Reel |  | Best for Budget-Friendly Simplicity | Suitable Pool Width: 9′-16′ | Included Components: Reel only, solar cover not included | Locking Handle: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 18ft Pool Cover Reel for Above Ground Pool |  | Best for Adjustable Fit and Durability | Maximum Width: 18 feet | Material: Aluminum, ABS | Extension Poles: 7 poles, 41.33 inches each | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 18ft Solar Pool Cover Reel for Above Ground Swimming Pool |  | Best for Heavy-Duty Use and Stability | Adjustable Width: 3.44 to 18 feet | Material: Aluminum, ABS | Weight Capacity: 55 pounds | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| VINGLI 18FT Pool Cover Reel for Inground Swimming Pools |  | Best for Versatile Pool Shapes and Portability | Pool Width Compatibility: 14 to 18 feet | Material: Aluminum, stainless steel | Design: Wheelbarrow-style, portable | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sun2Solar Solar Cover Reel System for Round or Oval Pools |  | Best for Large, Easy Operation Up to 21 Feet | Pool Size Compatibility: Up to 21 feet | Material: Plastic, aluminum | Assembly: Some assembly required | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Intex Heavy Duty Solar Pool Cover Reel with Locking Mechanism for Rectangle Frame Pools |  | Best Overall for Durability and Ease of Use | Material: Aluminum | Color: Black | Dimensions: 16 x 9 x 8.13 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| VINGLI 20 FT Pool Cover Reel, Retractable Solar Cover Reel |  | Best for Versatility and Mobility | Brand: VINGLI | Model Name: VINGLI G58000805+806+807+808 | Unit Count: 1 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Doheny’s Above Ground Solar Cover Reel System (Fits Pools Up to 18′ Wide, Deluxe Wheel) |  | Best for Ease of Operation and Compatibility | Brand: Doheny’s | UPC: 696859151224 | Manufacturer Part Number: 2827 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel for 24 ft Wide Above Ground Pools |  | Best for Larger Pools and Ease of Use | Fits Pool Width: 19-24 ft | Material: Resin | Color: Blue | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GLI Pool Products Whirlwind Above Ground Aluminum Solar Cover Reel (Various Widths) (18 Ft Wide) |  | Best for Wide Range of Pool Sizes and Heavy Duty Use | Material: Structural aluminum | Fits Pool Width: 18′ to 28′ | Height: 7.5 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| pool cover reels for above ground pool | Material |
|---|---|
| VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel f | — |
| Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel | Aluminum |
| Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel | Resin |
| SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Essential | — |
| 18FT Pool Cover Reel Set for I | — |
| Intex 28051E Solar Cover Reel | Plastic and metal |
| 18ft Pool Cover Reel for Above | Aluminum, ABS |
| 18ft Solar Pool Cover Reel for | Aluminum, ABS |
| VINGLI 18FT Pool Cover Reel fo | Aluminum, stainless steel |
| Sun2Solar Solar Cover Reel Sys | Plastic, aluminum |
| Intex Heavy Duty Solar Pool Co | Aluminum |
| VINGLI 20 FT Pool Cover Reel | — |
| Doheny’s Above Ground Solar Co | — |
| Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel | Resin |
| GLI Pool Products Whirlwind Ab | Structural aluminum |
More Details on Our Top Picks
VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel for Inground Swimming Pools
The VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel stands out for its sturdy, rust-resistant aluminum construction and easy one-hand crank operation, making it suitable for in-ground pools between 9 and 14 feet wide. Compared with the Horizon Lite reel, it offers more robust materials and a larger size range, though it may require some cutting to fit irregular shapes. Its portability with large wheels and lockable telescopic tube makes handling straightforward, especially for homeowners who need a reliable, long-lasting solution. The main tradeoff is its limited size compatibility, which means pools outside the 9-14 ft range will need a different model. This pick is ideal for owners of small to medium in-ground pools seeking durability and ease of use, but it isn’t the best choice for larger or irregularly shaped pools.
Pros:- Durable, rust-resistant aluminum construction
- Easy to assemble with a one-hand crank
- Portable with large wheels and lockable telescopic tube
- Suitable for various pool shapes and sizes
Cons:- May require cutting the cover for irregular pool shapes
- Assembly instructions could be clearer
- Limited to pools between 9 and 14 feet
Best for: Homeowners with in-ground pools between 9 and 14 feet wide seeking a durable, easy-to-operate reel
Not ideal for: Owners with pools outside this size range or irregular shapes, as they may need custom fitting or larger systems
- Model Name:Vingli pool reel
- Model Number:Vingli pool reel
- UPC:611890868436
- Item Type:21 ft. pool cover reel
- ASIN:B07M5T3X13
Our verdict“This reel provides a durable, adaptable solution for small to medium in-ground pools, perfect for homeowners prioritizing longevity and ease of use.”
Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel for 24 ft Above Ground Pools
The Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel is designed for pools up to 24 feet wide, making it a top choice for larger above ground pools. Its adjustable telescopic aluminum tubes ensure a snug fit, similar to the Horizon Lite reel but with a focus on larger sizes. The swing-away design allows for quick removal, which is handy for frequent use, and its USA-made construction offers reassurance on quality. Compared to less flexible models, this reel excels in size adjustability but might lack some refinement in operation. It’s best suited for owners of sizable above ground pools who want a reliable, adjustable reel that’s easy to maintain and operate.
Pros:- Adjustable to fit pools from 19 to 24 feet wide
- Easy to operate with a crank handle
- Durable aluminum construction
- Made in the USA with a 2-year warranty
Cons:- Limited to above ground pools only
- Customer ratings suggest some operational concerns
- Not suitable for soft-sided pools
Best for: Owners of large above ground pools (19-24 ft) needing a customizable, durable reel
Not ideal for: Pool owners with soft-sided pools or smaller pools below 19 feet, where the size might be excessive or fitment problematic
- Fits Pool Size:19-24 ft wide
- Material:Aluminum
- Diameter:3.5 ft
- Design:Telescopic, swing-away
- Made in:USA
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“This reel is ideal for large above ground pool owners seeking an adjustable, sturdy solution despite moderate customer feedback.”
Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel for 12-18 ft Above Ground Pools
The Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel is tailored for pools 12 to 18 feet wide, making it a practical choice for average-sized above ground pools. Its adjustable design and lightweight resin construction facilitate quick setup and easy manual operation, especially for one person, similar to the Nollapo model but with a focus on slightly smaller pools. The reel’s portability and simple assembly are advantageous for those who prefer a straightforward solution without complicated features. On the downside, its design may not accommodate pools larger than 18 feet, and manual operation could become tiresome with frequent use. Compared to the Horizon Elite, it’s a more affordable option with less size flexibility but still effective for smaller pool sizes. It’s best for owners who want an uncomplicated, portable reel for smaller pools.
Pros:- Adjustable to fit pools 12-18 ft wide
- Easy to operate with a crank handle
- Portable and quick to assemble
- Helps extend the life of solar blankets
Cons:- Design may not fit pools larger than 18 ft
- Manual operation can be tiring over time
- Limited to pools within specified size range
Best for: Homeowners with pools 12-18 ft wide seeking an easy-to-use, portable reel for regular use
Not ideal for: Owners of pools wider than 18 feet or those seeking automatic or semi-automatic operation
- Fits Pool Width:12-18 ft
- Material:Resin
- Color:Blue
- Item Dimensions:85″L x 7″W
- Outside Diameter:7 inches
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This reel offers a simple, portable solution for small to medium above ground pools, ideal for owners who prefer manual operation and easy setup.”
SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Essential 52000 Above Ground Pool Solar Reel System
The SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Essential 52000 emphasizes durability with its heavy-duty, weather-resistant construction, making it a solid choice for frequent use. Its socket-mount installation simplifies setup compared to models like the Horizon Elite, and it’s compatible with various tube kits sold separately—offering flexibility for customization. While the hardware is included, the need for additional tube kits and the separate purchase of accessories might be a drawback for those seeking an all-in-one solution. Compared to lighter reels, this system prioritizes robustness, which can justify its slightly higher complexity. It’s best for owners wanting a heavy-duty, reliable reel for frequent seasonal use on above ground pools but not for those seeking a plug-and-play, all-in-one package.
Pros:- Heavy-duty, weather-resistant construction
- Easy to install with socket mounting
- Includes hardware for setup
- Compatible with various tube kits for customization
Cons:- Tube kits are sold separately
- Requires additional purchase for full setup
- Limited to above ground pools
Best for: Above ground pool owners who want a durable, customizable solar reel system for regular use
Not ideal for: Owners seeking an all-in-one complete reel with no additional purchases or those with soft-sided pools
- Compatibility:Various tube kits (sold separately)
- Construction:Heavy-duty, non-corrosive
- Installation:Socket mountable
- Includes:Straps and hardware for solar blanket
Our verdict“This system is suited for owners prioritizing durability and customization over convenience and ready-to-use simplicity.”
18FT Pool Cover Reel Set for Inground Pools, Fits 6-18 ft Wide Pool
The Nollapo 18FT Pool Cover Reel offers a versatile, easy-to-operate solution for inground pools from 6 to 18 feet wide. Its sturdy, rust-resistant aluminum build and upgraded crank handle make rolling and unrolling effortless for a single person. Compared with the VINGLI reel, it provides a wider size range, making it suitable for a broader spectrum of pools. However, some users report that the crank may become less smooth over time, and assembly might require some adjustments for a perfect fit. This reel is a practical choice for owners of small to medium inground pools who want a durable, easy-to-use system that can adapt to different sizes. It is less ideal for larger pools or those seeking automatic operation.
Pros:- Adjustable to fit pools from 6 to 18 ft wide
- Heavy-duty aluminum construction resists rust
- Easy to operate with an upgraded crank handle
- Helps reduce evaporation and chemical loss
Cons:- Crank handle may become less smooth over time
- Some assembly or adjustments might be needed
- Limited to specified size range
Best for: Inground pool owners with pools 6-18 ft wide who want an adjustable, durable reel
Not ideal for: Owners of pools wider than 18 ft or those preferring automatic or semi-automatic reels
- Brand:Nollapo
- Model:NLA-1
- Model Number:NLA-1
- Inground Closure Type:Hook & Loop
- Unit Count:1
Our verdict“This adjustable, durable reel is well-suited for inground pool owners seeking a reliable, versatile system within a broad size range.”
Intex 28051E Solar Cover Reel
The Intex 28051E Solar Cover Reel stands out for its straightforward design that simplifies the process of covering and uncovering pools between 9 and 16 feet wide. Unlike larger, more complex reels like the VINGLI 18FT Pool Cover Reel, this reel is easy to install and operate without the need for extensive tools or adjustments. Its locking handle enhances safety by preventing unintentional unrolling, but it’s important to note that the reel is sold without a solar cover, which adds to the overall cost. This model is ideal for pool owners seeking a basic, reliable solution, especially those with rectangular pools. However, it’s limited to pools of specific widths and doesn’t include the solar cover, making it less suitable for users who want an all-in-one package or have irregular pool shapes.
Pros:- Simple to install and operate with minimal tools
- Locks securely to prevent unrolling during use
- Compatible with pools 9 to 16 feet wide, covering common sizes
Cons:- Reel only; solar cover must be purchased separately
- Limited to rectangular pools, reducing versatility
- No included solar cover or accessories
Best for: Pool owners with rectangular above-ground pools between 9 to 16 feet wide who want an affordable, easy-to-use reel.
Not ideal for: Homeowners with irregularly shaped pools or those looking for an all-in-one solution, since the solar cover is sold separately and the reel only fits certain pool sizes.
- Suitable Pool Width:9′-16′
- Included Components:Reel only, solar cover not included
- Locking Handle:Yes
- Material:Plastic and metal
- Installation:Easy, attaches directly to pool frame
- Weight Capacity:Not specified
Our verdict“This reel makes the most sense for budget-conscious owners with standard rectangular pools who want a straightforward, no-fuss solution.”
18ft Pool Cover Reel for Above Ground Pool
This 18ft Pool Cover Reel offers versatility with its adjustable design, making it well-suited for a variety of pool sizes up to 18 feet wide. Compared to the Sun2Solar Reel System, it features a robust rust-resistant aluminum frame and a straightforward locking mechanism that ensures smooth operation. While its adjustable range is a major strength, the relatively low customer rating hints at potential issues with assembly or durability, which might deter some buyers. Its limited information on included accessories also leaves questions about complete setup, making it more suitable for experienced pool owners comfortable with assembly. If you want a durable, adjustable reel but are wary of potential quality issues, this model warrants careful consideration.
Pros:- Adjustable to fit a range of pool sizes up to 18 feet
- Rust-resistant aluminum and ABS construction for longevity
- Easy to operate with locking and smooth winding features
Cons:- Relatively low customer ratings, indicating possible quality issues
- Limited details on included accessories or comprehensive setup instructions
Best for: Experienced pool owners seeking a durable, adjustable reel that can fit various above-ground pools up to 18 feet wide.
Not ideal for: Casual users or those new to pool maintenance who might find the assembly and durability concerns problematic.
- Maximum Width:18 feet
- Material:Aluminum, ABS
- Extension Poles:7 poles, 41.33 inches each
- Short Pole:12.59 inches
- Locking Mechanism:Yes
- Weight Capacity:55 pounds
Our verdict“This reel is suited for experienced owners who need adjustable durability but should be aware of possible quality concerns.”
18ft Solar Pool Cover Reel for Above Ground Swimming Pool
The 18ft Solar Pool Cover Reel excels at heavy-duty applications, with its robust aluminum and ABS construction combined with a 55-pound capacity that handles thicker solar covers with ease. Its adjustable design, fitting pools from 3.44 to 18 feet, makes it flexible for various above-ground pools. Unlike smaller or less sturdy models like the Intex Solar Cover Reel, this reel is built for durability and stability, featuring a locking mechanism that prevents unwanted movement. However, it requires manual adjustments for different pool sizes, and some users might find assembly or setup less intuitive. This reel is perfect for pool owners needing a heavy-duty, adjustable solution, but it may be overkill for those with simpler needs or smaller pools.
Pros:- Adjustable width from 3.44 to 18 feet for versatility
- Heavy-duty, rust-resistant aluminum and ABS construction
- Locking mechanism for stability during use
- Handles heavy covers with a 55-pound capacity
Cons:- Requires manual adjustment for different pool widths
- Potentially complex setup for first-time users
Best for: Above-ground pool owners with larger or heavier solar covers who want a stable, heavy-duty reel with adjustable width.
Not ideal for: Owners of small pools or those seeking a lightweight, minimalist solution, as it’s designed primarily for durability over portability.
- Adjustable Width:3.44 to 18 feet
- Material:Aluminum, ABS
- Weight Capacity:55 pounds
- Pool Edge Compatibility:0.86 to 1.85 inches
- Pole Lengths:7 rods, 41.33 inches each
Our verdict“This reel is ideal for larger or heavier solar covers needing a stable, adjustable frame, though it demands some effort to set up.”
VINGLI 18FT Pool Cover Reel for Inground Swimming Pools
The VINGLI 18FT Pool Cover Reel is designed with versatility in mind, fitting pools up to 18 feet wide, including some irregular shapes thanks to its portable, wheel barrow-style design. Its durable aluminum and stainless steel build ensures longevity, and the lockable telescopic tube provides easy one-handed operation. Compared to fixed-frame reels, this model offers greater mobility, making it easier to store or reposition. However, it requires cutting the solar cover to fit some pool shapes, which could be a downside for owners looking for a ready-made fit. Its detailed assembly instructions are not included, which may challenge less experienced users. This reel makes sense for those who value portability and adjustable fit, especially with irregular pool shapes.
Pros:- Easy to maneuver with large wheels and portable design
- Durable aluminum and stainless steel construction
- Lockable telescopic tube for one-hand operation
- Fits pools up to 18 feet wide, including irregular shapes
Cons:- Requires cutting the cover to fit irregular shapes
- Assembly instructions are not detailed or included
- Potential shipping damage if not handled properly
Best for: Pool owners with irregular or uniquely shaped pools up to 18 feet wide who need a portable, adjustable cover reel.
Not ideal for: Owners with standard rectangular pools who prefer a fixed, no-cut solution or those uncomfortable with assembly ambiguity.
- Pool Width Compatibility:14 to 18 feet
- Material:Aluminum, stainless steel
- Design:Wheelbarrow-style, portable
- Locking Mechanism:Yes
Our verdict“This reel offers excellent portability and adaptability for irregular pools but demands some DIY adjustments for optimal fit.”
Sun2Solar Solar Cover Reel System for Round or Oval Pools
The Sun2Solar Reel System offers the broadest compatibility, fitting pools up to 21 feet wide, whether round or oval, making it suitable for larger above-ground pools. Its lightweight, non-corrosive materials simplify installation and handling, especially compared to heavier, fixed-reel options like the Horizon Elite. The one-person operation via a steering wheel handle enhances convenience, but the system is not designed for covers larger than 20 feet unless folded, which limits its use for very large covers. Additionally, it’s not suitable for covers thicker than 16 mil, so users should verify their solar cover specifications. This reel benefits owners of larger, shaped pools who prioritize ease of use and portability but might find it less ideal for oversized or thicker covers.
Pros:- Easy one-person operation with steering wheel handle
- Lightweight, corrosion-resistant materials
- Includes all hardware for straightforward installation
- Fits pools up to 21 feet wide
Cons:- Limited to covers under 20 feet unless folded
- Not suitable for thicker, 16-mil solar covers
- Some assembly required
Best for: Owners of large, round, or oval above-ground pools up to 21 feet wide who want an easy, lightweight reel system for solar covers.
Not ideal for: Pool owners with extremely large or thick solar covers exceeding 20 feet or those preferring permanent, fixed reels.
- Pool Size Compatibility:Up to 21 feet
- Material:Plastic, aluminum
- Assembly:Some assembly required
- Warranty:3 years
Our verdict“This system excels for large pools up to 21 feet, offering simple handling but limited for very thick or oversized covers.”
Intex Heavy Duty Solar Pool Cover Reel with Locking Mechanism for Rectangle Frame Pools
This reel stands out for its robust aluminum construction, making it a reliable choice for frequent use and long-term durability. Compared to the Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel, it offers a more heavy-duty build, though it is limited to rectangular pools between 9 and 16 feet wide. Its locking handle enhances safety by preventing unintentional unrolling, a feature missing from some basic models. However, it doesn’t include a solar cover, so you’ll need to purchase one separately, and its design is restricted to rectangular pools, which limits versatility. This reel makes the most sense for pool owners with rectangular frames seeking a durable, straightforward solution that prioritizes longevity over multi-pool adaptability.
Pros:- Heavy-duty aluminum construction for long-lasting durability
- Easy to install and operate with a locking handle
- Suitable for pools 9 to 16 feet wide
Cons:- Cover not included, requiring an additional purchase
- Limited to rectangular pools only, reducing versatility
Best for: Homeowners with rectangular frame pools needing a sturdy, reliable reel that simplifies cover handling.
Not ideal for: Owners of soft-sided or irregularly shaped pools, as it is designed specifically for rigid rectangular pools and does not include a cover.
- Material:Aluminum
- Color:Black
- Dimensions:16 x 9 x 8.13 inches
- Weight:17.15 pounds
- Suitable Pool Size:9 to 16 feet wide
Our verdict“This reel is best suited for owners of rectangular pools who prioritize durability and straightforward operation.”
VINGLI 20 FT Pool Cover Reel, Retractable Solar Cover Reel
This reel offers a flexible, adjustable design with telescoping aluminum tubing and a wheeled base, making it ideal for pools that change shape or size. Unlike the Horizon Lite for 24 ft pools, the VINGLI reel is more adaptable to different pool setups, though it may require some assembly and adjustment to achieve the perfect fit. Its heavy-duty materials prevent sagging, and the stability provided by the triangular support structure enhances safety during operation. Its mobility, however, can be a drawback if you need a fixed, permanent solution, and limited detailed user reviews make assessing long-term reliability difficult. This pick is perfect for pool owners who value mobility and adjustable sizing over a fixed, dedicated reel system.
Pros:- Adjustable height and telescoping design for versatile use
- Heavy-duty aluminum prevents sagging
- Wheeled base allows easy mobility
Cons:- May require assembly or adjustment for perfect fit
- Multiple packages due to size can complicate delivery
Best for: Pool owners with variable pool sizes or those who want to easily move the reel around without permanent installation.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a simple, fixed reel for a dedicated pool, as the assembly and adjustment can be cumbersome, and the reel might require ongoing tweaks.
- Brand:VINGLI
- Model Name:VINGLI G58000805+806+807+808
- Unit Count:1
- Pool Safety Products Rank:#1,350
Our verdict“This reel is ideal for owners who need a portable, adaptable solution for varying pool sizes and shapes.”
Doheny’s Above Ground Solar Cover Reel System (Fits Pools Up to 18′ Wide, Deluxe Wheel)
This reel is designed for quick, user-friendly operation with options for single-hand crank or dual wheels, making it a strong choice for owners who want straightforward functionality. Unlike the Horizon Lite, which is more adjustable for various sizes, Doheny’s reel is tailored for pools up to 18 feet wide, with durable materials like aluminum and UV-inhibited plastic that resist corrosion. The included hardware simplifies installation, but it’s not compatible with soft-sided pools, and its size limit means it won’t suit larger pools. This reel is best for those seeking a durable, easy-to-use system specifically for standard-sized above ground pools up to 18 feet wide.
Pros:- Easy to operate with single-hand crank or dual wheels
- Durable materials including aluminum and UV plastic
- Complete hardware for quick installation
Cons:- Limited to pools up to 18 feet wide
- Not compatible with soft-sided pools
Best for: Homeowners with pools up to 18 feet wide who prioritize quick setup and simple operation.
Not ideal for: Owners of larger pools or soft-sided pools, since it is designed for specific sizes and rigid pool structures.
- Brand:Doheny’s
- UPC:696859151224
- Manufacturer Part Number:2827
- Fits Pool Width:up to 18 feet
- Compatible Cover Thickness:up to 12 mil
- Warranty:1 Year
Our verdict“This reel is a smart choice for owners of standard-sized pools who want reliability and quick setup without fuss.”
Horizon Lite Solar Cover Reel for 24 ft Wide Above Ground Pools
This reel shines in its compatibility with larger pools up to 24 feet wide, thanks to its adjustable telescopic design that fits oval and round shapes. Compared to the Whirlwind aluminum reel, it offers easier portability and simpler operation, especially for single users. Made from resin, it is lightweight yet sturdy enough for regular use, and the crank handle allows for one-person operation. However, it’s limited to pools up to 24 feet, so owners of larger or irregularly shaped pools may need a different system. It’s ideal for owners of sizeable above-ground pools who want quick, one-person operation without sacrificing adjustability.
Pros:- Adjustable to fit pools up to 24 ft wide
- Easy one-person operation with a crank handle
- Helps extend solar blanket life and reduce heat loss
Cons:- Designed specifically for above ground pools, not inground
- Optional mounting clips may be needed for soft-sided pools
Best for: Owners of larger above-ground pools up to 24 feet in width seeking a lightweight, adjustable reel.
Not ideal for: Pool owners with pools wider than 24 feet or with irregular shapes that require a more heavy-duty or fixed solution.
- Fits Pool Width:19-24 ft
- Material:Resin
- Color:Blue
- Item Dimensions:85″L x 7″W
- Outside Diameter:1.5 inches
- Item Length:7.08 feet
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This reel is well-suited for large above-ground pools up to 24 feet, especially if portability and ease of use are priorities.”
GLI Pool Products Whirlwind Above Ground Aluminum Solar Cover Reel (Various Widths) (18 Ft Wide)
The Whirlwind reel offers a durable, high-quality aluminum build that supports pools from 18 to 28 feet wide, providing excellent flexibility for different pool sizes. Its sturdy construction and included hardware make operation smooth for a single person, similar to the Horizon Lite but with a broader size range. Unlike the Horizon Lite, which is more lightweight and suited to smaller setups, the Whirlwind is designed for owners of larger pools who want a long-lasting, easy-to-operate system. The main tradeoff is that it requires mounting on the pool’s top rail, which can be more involved during setup. This reel makes sense for owners needing a robust, multi-size system that can handle larger pools with minimal effort.
Pros:- Durable structural aluminum construction
- Fits a wide range of pool widths (18′-28′)
- Includes all hardware for easy attachment
Cons:- Requires mounting on the pool’s top rail, which may be more complex
- Solar cover not included, needing separate purchase
Best for: Owners of pools between 18 and 28 feet wide who want a durable, easy-to-operate aluminum reel for long-term use.
Not ideal for: Owners with smaller pools or those who prefer a reel that doesn’t require mounting on the top rail, as installation can be more involved.
- Material:Structural aluminum
- Fits Pool Width:18′ to 28′
- Height:7.5 inches
- Base Dimensions:3 5/8 W x 5 1/4 L inches
- Warranty:1 year full, 5 years limited
- Mounting:Top rail of above ground pool
Our verdict“This reel is best for owners of large pools seeking a heavy-duty, versatile, and easy-to-operate system with durable materials.”
How We Picked
These products were evaluated based on build quality, ease of installation and operation, compatibility with common pool sizes, durability in outdoor conditions, and overall value. We prioritized models that offer a good balance between affordability and long-term performance, with particular attention to rust resistance and ease of use features. The rankings reflect how well each reel performs in everyday use, with extra points for innovative design elements or added safety features. Products were also assessed for customer feedback and warranty offerings to ensure reliability and support for buyers.Factors to Consider When Choosing Pool Cover Reels For Above Ground Pools
Choosing the right pool cover reel involves considering several factors that can impact your experience and the longevity of your pool cover. While price is important, features like durability, ease of use, and compatibility often outweigh initial savings. Understanding these key considerations can help you avoid common pitfalls, such as selecting a reel that doesn’t fit your pool size or one that deteriorates quickly under outdoor conditions. Here are the main factors to weigh when selecting a reel for your above ground pool.Pool Size and Compatibility
Reels come in various sizes, typically designed for pools ranging from 12 to 24 feet wide. Ensuring the reel matches your pool’s dimensions is critical for proper coverage and ease of operation. Some reels are adjustable or available in different widths, offering flexibility. Choosing a reel that fits too tightly or loosely can lead to difficulty in rolling or damage over time. Measure your pool accurately and verify the reel’s specifications before purchasing.
Material Durability and Weather Resistance
Since these reels are stored outdoors, their materials must withstand exposure to sun, rain, and temperature fluctuations. Look for corrosion-resistant metals like aluminum or coated steel, along with weatherproof plastics. Cheaper reels made from non-resistant materials often rust or degrade quickly, resulting in costly replacements. Investing in a durable model can save money and frustration over multiple seasons.
Ease of Use and Safety Features
Features like smooth-rolling mechanisms, locking systems, and lightweight designs make operation more manageable, especially for those with limited strength or mobility. A reel with a locking feature prevents unintentional unwinding, adding safety. Conversely, some budget models may lack these features, leading to more manual effort or potential safety hazards. Consider how often you will operate the reel and choose a model that minimizes effort and maximizes safety.
Installation and Compatibility with Pool Shape
Most reels are designed for round pools, but oval or irregular shapes may require specific models or custom solutions. Installation ease varies, with some reels attaching quickly with minimal tools, while others might need more effort or adjustments. Check manufacturer instructions and compatibility notes to ensure the reel will fit your pool without additional modifications. Proper fit and straightforward installation can significantly reduce setup time and frustration.
Price and Long-term Value
While budget options can be tempting, they often compromise on durability or features. Conversely, premium models tend to offer better materials and additional safety features but at a higher upfront cost. Think about your long-term needs and whether investing more now will reduce replacement costs later. Sometimes, paying a bit more for a reliable, durable reel results in better value over several seasons.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install a reel myself, or do I need professional help?
Most pool cover reels are designed for straightforward installation that can be handled by homeowners with basic tools. Many models include clear instructions and minimal hardware, making DIY setup feasible. However, for larger or more complex installations, especially on irregularly shaped pools, seeking professional assistance can ensure proper mounting and alignment. Proper installation is key to the reel’s longevity and safe operation.
Are there reels suitable for both round and oval pools?
While many reels are designed specifically for round pools, some models feature adjustable or customizable components that can accommodate oval or irregular shapes. It’s important to verify the product specifications and mounting options before purchasing. If you have a non-standard shape, look for reels that explicitly mention compatibility or consider custom solutions to ensure secure fit and ease of use.
How do I maintain my pool reel to extend its lifespan?
Regular maintenance includes cleaning off dirt, debris, and salt that can cause corrosion, especially on metal components. Lubricating moving parts periodically ensures smooth operation, while inspecting for rust or damage allows early intervention. Covering the reel during off-seasons or when not in use helps protect it from unnecessary exposure. Proper storage and routine checks can significantly prolong the life of your reel.
Is a locking mechanism necessary for a pool reel?
Yes, a locking mechanism provides added safety by securing the reel in place when not in use or during windy conditions. It prevents accidental unwinding or unwinding caused by weather, reducing the risk of damage or injury. Reels without locks may require more manual control and can be more challenging to operate safely, especially if children or pets are nearby.
What is the typical lifespan of a good quality pool cover reel?
With proper maintenance and suitable weather protection, a high-quality reel can last anywhere from 5 to 10 years. Cheaper models may only last 2-3 seasons before rust, warping, or mechanical failure occurs. Investing in a well-made, weather-resistant model can significantly extend its usability, making it a worthwhile long-term purchase for regular pool owners.
Conclusion
For most above ground pool owners, the VINGLI 21FT Solar Cover Reel offers the best overall combination of durability, ease of use, and affordability, making it ideal for regular seasonal use. Those with larger pools or seeking premium features should consider the Horizon Elite Solar Cover Reel, which provides enhanced durability and safety features. Budget-conscious buyers can find reliable options like the Intex 28051E Solar Cover Reel that deliver good value for occasional use. Beginners or homeowners with smaller pools will benefit from simpler, lightweight models such as the Intex Heavy Duty Solar Pool Cover Reel. Ultimately, selecting the right reel depends on pool size, frequency of use, and long-term maintenance plans — matching these factors ensures your above ground pool stays protected and easy to manage year after year.
